OSDP vs. Wiegand: Upgrade Your Access Control System

| Knowledge

Alright, let’s talk access control – the tech that determines whether you walk through the door like a VIP or get stopped like an imposter in a bad heist movie.

If you’re in the security industry, you know that for decades, Wiegand has been the standard for reader-to-controller communication. But here’s the problem: Wiegand is ancient. It’s the flip phone of access control – reliable, sure, but totally outdated.

Enter OSDP (Open Supervised Device Protocol), the new kid on the block. And unlike Wiegand, which is basically sending passwords through a megaphone, OSDP is like using an encrypted, secured private line.

Let’s break it down.

Wiegand: The Dinosaur That Won’t Die

Wiegand has been around since the 80s (yes, the same decade that gave us floppy disks and mullets). It was a game-changer back then, but today? It’s barely keeping up.

The Problems with Wiegand:

  1. Zero Encryption – Wiegand transmits data in plain text. That means if someone intercepts the signal, they can clone your access card in minutes. Not ideal.
  2. One-Way Communication – It’s like shouting at your security system with no way for it to reply. The reader sends data to the controller, but the controller can’t send anything back.
  3. No Supervision – If someone cuts a Wiegand cable, guess what? The system doesn’t even notice. That’s like leaving your front door open and assuming no one will walk in.

Despite these issues, Wiegand is still everywhere – because it works, it’s cheap, and upgrading access control is a pain. But companies sticking with it are leaving themselves wide open to hacking and inefficiencies.

OSDP: The Secure, Smart Upgrade

Now let’s talk about OSDP – the Tesla of access control. It was developed by the Security Industry Association (SIA) to fix everything wrong with Wiegand.

Here’s why OSDP wins:

  1. Encryption & Security
    • Unlike Wiegand, OSDP is fully encrypted using AES-128. That means even if someone intercepts the data, it’s useless to them.
    • No more card cloning or skimming attacks – this is security done right.
  2. Two-Way Communication
    • OSDP lets the reader and controller talk to each other.
    • Example: If a reader is tampered with, it can send a real-time alert instead of staying silent like Wiegand.
  3. Supervision & Health Monitoring
    • OSDP continuously checks if devices are connected and working properly. If someone cuts a cable or a reader goes offline, the system knows immediately.
    • No more “we found out days later” moments.
  4. Longer Range & Better Cabling
    • Wiegand struggles beyond 500 feet.
    • OSDP? Up to 4,000 feet using RS-485 twisted pair. That’s 8x the range, meaning fewer controllers and cleaner installs.
  5. Standardisation & Interoperability
    • Wiegand is proprietary, meaning different vendors’ devices don’t always play nice.
    • OSDP is an open standard, meaning you can mix and match vendors, integrate with newer tech, and future-proof your system.
  6. Support for Advanced Features
    • With OSDP, you get native support for things like biometrics, smartcards, and touchscreen PIN pads.
    • Wiegand? Still stuck in the “scan and hope for the best” era.

Desfire EV3 & Site Code Matching: The Extra Security Layer

Now, let’s talk about an extra layer of security that many businesses ignore: readers that support site codes and match them with the site code on a Desfire EV3 card.

Why does this matter?

  1. Stops Unauthorised Card Duplication
    • Traditional Wiegand and older MIFARE cards can be cloned with off-the-shelf devices.
    • Desfire EV3 + site code validation prevents cloned cards from working because the reader checks for a specific site code before granting access.
  2. Eliminates Unauthorised Aftermarket Cards
    • One of the biggest vulnerabilities is employees or outsiders purchasing blank cards online and programming them with stolen credentials.
    • With a properly configured OSDP reader + Desfire EV3 + site code enforcement, only officially issued cards work.
  3. Future-Proofs Your System
    • Many legacy systems are vulnerable to card replay attacks (where an attacker captures a card’s transmission and replays it to gain access).
    • Desfire EV3 adds transaction protection to prevent replay attacks, and site code enforcement ensures only legitimate, site-specific cards are allowed.

What This Means for End Users

For security managers, IT directors, and business owners, the message is clear: Wiegand is a security risk, and OSDP with Desfire EV3 and site code validation is the way forward.

  • If you care about security, OSDP eliminates eavesdropping risks, card cloning, and system blind spots.
  • If you want to stop unauthorised access, site code validation ensures only genuine, site-approved cards work.
  • If you manage multiple buildings, Desfire EV3 ensures seamless, controlled access between sites.
  • If you want to future-proof your investment, OSDP’s open standard ensures your system won’t be obsolete in 5 years.

The bottom line?

If you’re still using Wiegand in 2025, you’re basically using a fax machine for security. It’s time to upgrade to OSDP with Desfire EV3 before someone walks through your “secure” doors using a £30 device they bought online.

Your move.

Scroll to Top